Johns Incredible Pizza - Montclair in Montclair

I was in walking distance since I was getting my car worked on not too far away. So I decided to go in. One of the real decisions Ive made. For a buffet it wasnt really set up. It didnt have many items available and the things they had available only had a few of them in there. Couldnt get a piece of chicken to save my life. I asked for a vegetarian pizza and it took so long for it to come out. I had to keep reminding them about it. I wanted to try the chili but it didnt seem to be up to temperature nor did any of the other sauces. And of course and close to $20. I much rather went to a Chinese buffet or Golden corral. The pizza was not very good. I expected more for the price. But they do have a sports room with that. It might be cool to watch a football game.

Games are great for the kids but I truly wish this establishment would care for the cleanliness. All the seats were dirty all the tables were dirty and the table next to us hadn’t been cleaned the whole 45 mins we were eating. The staff seemed more concerned about after work activities than their jobs. This place has potential if the staff would be more on top of things. Cleanliness around the buffet is not up to par, understandably the amount of customers coming through it can get messy but the forks aren’t even properly cleaned and the staff didn’t seem to have motivation to clean. Not sure if our family would return but I hope this inspires the staff and management to improve

Pizza and fun. Just like old Chuck E. Cheese. Place perfect for bday party for the kiddies. Pizza is greasy and buffet is meh. If you under 10 years old. This is your jam.

Food was Okay, they could have had more of a variety. Their chicken nuggets were great I thought. A variety of different pizzas to choose from but could have been more under the heat lamps. Didnt get to try their baked potato or a majority of other options. But the fact that it wasnt so crowded at the time we arrived was great! Had a wonderful time with friends and family 👪💕💕💕💛🕊🌈

The food was good and had enough options for everyone. The pizza and chicken wings were good and their is soda as well. They also regularly put out new food.The service was good nothing bad to say.The atmosphere is interesting. For the buffet area their are room with their own themes. A Hawaii style, a lodge, sports fan, and a normal looking one.One qualm I have is that some arcade games are expensive and I have never seen every game work. The tickets you earn arent much and the prizes are meh at best.(Though there is a switch with a HUGE ticket price)Overall my experience was good and fun.

Great place for young kids to have a fun time with friends. Many different pizzas to choose from, an endless amount food and sweets so you get your money worth. The twister ride is fun they also have bumper cars and a black light golf course and many games to play for all age groups. It seemed like they need more workers on the game floor. My family and I will return here again we always have a really good time.

Great spot for kids. Prepare for a very loud environment. When entering you have to use kiosk which I don’t think that’s very smart.. that area gets way to congested. I feel the only workers there was the bartender and cooks.. If you have no kids I would not recommend going for a date night.

Perfect place to take the kids for some entertainment. Could be crowded at times, but overall, it wasnt too expensive. The food was a lot of carby, starch pizza but not bad, alot of pantries. Had a good time with my kids to build memories.

Good prices, food is okay but does offer a good selection of pizza, different themed rooms offer something for most people going to be comfortable but can get full on the weekends. Eating space by the games is nice and offers extra seating if you dont mind the noise. Games do get updated often and have a good variety.

A lot of staff but not helpful. We arrived shortly after noon on a Tuesday. The food did not seem fresh or plentiful. Salad bar was nice and cold but not a lot of selection. About 2 pm the food was refreshed and better selection. The children had fun!