Presentation on Map Reviews Nearby

Milk & Cookie Bar in Castro Valley

4.5 (60) 18911 Lake Chabot Rd, Castro Valley, CA 94546, United States

Categories

Ice cream shop

Location on the map

Castro Valley, Alameda County, California, US

Phone: +1 510-397-0189
Site: https://milkandcookiebar.com/

Opening hours

Monday:12–8 PM
Tuesday:12–8 PM
Wednesday:12–8 PM
Thursday:12–8 PM
Friday:12–8 PM
Saturday:12–8 PM
Sunday:12–7 PM

Edit info

Total reviews rating 4.5

60 Reviews for Milk & Cookie Bar 2024:

Review №1

2022-06-29 04:30:12

Have wanted to try one of these beautiful creations for awhile. Went mid afternoon which was perfect it wasnt crazy crowded so I was able to figure out what combination I wanted.Ordered:📍 Doughboy shakeNutella ice cream, dark chocolate drizzle, waffle cone bits and Oreo cookie crumbles, plus the mini donuts on the straw and a scoop of Ube topped it all off whew, so rich only thing I would do differently next time is bring a couple friends to share it withSo good but so much! No way I could finish this is definitely a dessert creation to share.

Review №2

2023-11-26 22:09:35

A little $$ but, WOW. I had a black sesame ice cream shake, and it was DELICIOUS AND DECADENT.

Review №3

2021-07-14 20:41:50

Delicious. So fun to make your own ice cream cookie sandwich (or ice cream stuffed donut). The ice cream is smooth and creamy. Although the Cookie Monster is very blue & now so are our mouths. Totally worth it. Delicious. And also very sweet customer service. It’s just a little loud inside the building and it wasn’t very busy when we went.

Review №4

2022-05-17 07:37:56

Just delicious ice cream. I recommend! You can visit with children. I would like to note the fact that their owner has changed, which means that the topping supplier has changed. So the taste will be a little different than before. I like the fruity taste of ice cream. Its great that there is such a shop in this area.

Review №5

2021-10-09 23:41:59

So yummy! And the portions are huge. We were all struggling to finish.... Jasmine Oreo is very jasmine and not very sweet. Mint Oreo is fantastic.

Review №6

2021-09-14 19:05:48

The ice cream was good and the cookie!! It’s affordable and the area has other restaurants as well, it was a very chill environment. The only thing I didn’t like if that they wrapped my ice cream in this paper like wrapping...it was very messy once the ice cream started quickly melting so I’d suggest asking for a cup or bowl if they have one. Or just eat it there but it made a mess in my car. Employees were really nice!

Review №7

2019-11-26 16:26:05

This place is incredible! We love the ice cream and the creativity so much we used them for our desert for our wedding! He was so helpful and accommodating and even created our own ice cream flavors!

Review №8

2023-10-08 04:30:59

This place is a must visit again its located in a food court thats well kept and surrounded by yummies. I really enjoyed the different variety of ice-creams we will definitely be going back.

Review №9

2022-08-01 00:59:14

The two workers that were there on 6/31 around 5pm, were sooo sweet! My daughter spilled her fruity pebbles bc she fell and they helped us clean it up + gave her more!

Review №10

2023-07-23 19:45:01

Great flavors! I had the jasmine Oreo but was curious about the black sesame and Thai tea cookie dough.

Review №11

2018-08-20 15:37:14

This place is super cute. Has multiple food places inside and it’s a tiny Korean market. Their Icecream reminds me of Afters. They had donuts, rice Krispy treats and and one more item (I forgot) to make Icecream sammiches. I got the horchata cake, and my aunt got the strawberry matcha. It comes with 2 free items and we got the picky and strawberry pearls. The girl who helped us was really nice and their Icecream was sweet and good. Would come back! It was around $8 for two scoops and a rice krispy treat.

Review №12

2019-03-26 13:56:22

I found this place on Google and I was attracted by the pictures, it seemed a nice place to take the family for some Ice cream.Well, my shake, I feel it was delicious, better than I imagined :).The place is located inside a location, so they could do better at putting signs outside so people know, because I missed it, but other than that, love the presentation of their ice cream, shakes, etc.

Review №13

2019-12-06 06:16:39

I saw a post on Facebook about this place about a year ago. Finally made it there today. I had the Black Unicorn milkshake topped with lucky charms marshmellows, cookies & cream crunch, donut holes and whipped cream. My daughter had 1 scoop of the Black Unicorn icecream topped with sour candy worms and rainbow sprinkles and my husband had the elmo cookies and cream icecream in between a sliced glazed donut. His icecream isnt pictured because he was almost done with it before I was able to take pictures.

Review №14

2023-02-04 22:44:34

Had a mango dughboy milkshake, my husband had a cookies and cream cookie sandwich and kids tried strawberry brownie ice cream and pumpkin spice ice cream. The munchkins weree really good as was the ice cream my kids got. Personally wasnt crazy about the mango milkshake I feel like the ice cream could be sweeter. And the cookies were too hard

Review №15

2023-11-06 01:42:18

Small place inside the market. Not a ton of flavors, but you are bound to fond something you like.

Review №16

2022-09-10 02:17:47

Its our first time here. Im not sure if flavor varies all the time but I tried the guava sorbet and Love it!! For others, guava maybe an acquired taste but if you are used to it then I hope youll enjoy it. Must try and recommend it.

Review №17

2021-07-15 03:32:24

My black sesame and matcha Oreo flavors were great! I was surprised that there werent any of their cookies or donuts on display. I will definitely be back to try strawberry Pop-Tart sometime.

Review №18

2022-01-22 23:30:17

Nice selection of unique ice cream flavors. Brownie cookie butter and the animal cookie were my personal favorites. Cinnamon toast crunch was a good topping.

Review №19

2016-08-20 23:05:18

So good! Glad I dont live nearby because Id be fat as a blimp! Its so amazing! They always have unique flavors of ice cream! Last week, jasmine milk tea, this week Thai tea! Whats next week going to bring? They make whatever flavor they want! Super creative!!

Review №20

2016-05-26 23:15:09

First, Dave and company have the best customer service! The ice cream flavors are amazing with a vast flavor availability from savory to sweet with everything in-between. The crunch combos and sauce are endless giving you a fresh mix everytime you come in.The prices per item are fair for the quality and quantity received. Bonus: Milk and Cookie Bar uses the Five-star rewards program so you dont have to track anything!

Review №21

2016-05-13 19:38:07

I love the texture and density of this ice cream -- its creamy and chewy. Flavors are amazing. I tried the ube (its like a purple sweet potato) and will be craving that for days to come! I want to come back and try Mint Marshmallow Party. Theyve also got a lot of fun combos (cookies and doughnuts) and toppings to go with your ice cream.

Review №22

2020-09-02 01:57:55

Great ice cream and unique flavors. Yum. Coffee Oreo cookie dough? Omg this is my favorite flavor ever. I want to stock my fridge with that banana Oreo and Thai tea. Miss the Vietnamese coffee flavor too. All employees working there have always had great customer service. Need to stock up when they open Saturday. This is probably the greatest coping with covid snack out there. If you guys want some unsolicited inspiration here’s some random ideas.Creme Brûlée / CustardThai tea with bobaHoney pistachio walnutCinnamon raisin cornflakesShort bread and strawberryPeanut butter and jellyButter beerCarmel macchiatoThanks giving flavors:Maple graham crackerCandied yamsPumpkin spice OreoChristmas:Candy cane chocolateEgg Nogg and nilla waferGinger thin x toffeeRev 2:Pistachio OreoThin Mint Cookie X PistachioHazelnut cookie doughCaribbean Passion: Banana X strawberry x mango swirlDragonfruit powder x Strawberry x VanillaStrawberry x OrangeVanilla bean x lavenderEuro Road Peanut butter chocolate base x hazelnut chunks x marshmallow piecesUbe x Oreo x Peanut

Review №23

2023-03-16 02:29:06

The blue donut shake thing was excellent. Added bonus, it gives you green bowel movements. Really, youll poop green.

Review №24

2017-06-02 01:13:25

If you need a mid-day pick-me-up treat, this is your spot in the East Bay. Make sure to sample the flavors when youre there -- theyre doing some cool ones like black unicorn, Lucky Charms, jasmine oreo, and more. Whats awesome is how photo-worthy these treats are! No matter if youre getting a milkshake, donut ice cream sandwich or rice krispy ice cream, you can add colorful toppings!

Review №25

2017-09-17 21:35:35

Customer service is ok. What I didnt like us how they felt they had to compare to Cloud 9 (I dont work for them for the record) ... If your product is good on its own dont bash someone elses.Ice cream in a donut is bomb but I think a ice cream burger is pretty bomb too...

Review №26

2019-04-04 14:44:07

Cookie monster and Circus animal ice cream is my fave. They make all these different flavors with a twist! Definately should go try this. I always get the doughboy which is like an ice cream sandwhich but using a donut with the ice cream inside it. Not overly sweet just perfect.

Review №27

2019-03-05 02:29:43

They have much more but... Donuts and ice cream is what I come for!Must recommend the cookie monster!

Review №28

2018-05-27 15:45:34

Love this place and take everyone there!! Seriously IV introduce about 12 people and each one loves it. If you like boring ice cream not the place for you. But if your looking for something fresh and new flavors best place in the bay right now!

Review №29

2020-11-23 22:21:20

My kids love this place! Their ube ice cream is one of our favorites.

Review №30

2016-02-01 00:34:10

The ratio of cookie to ice cream is really off. I got the ube ice cream with oatmeal cookies and it really just tasted only like oatmeal. I think the scoop of ice cream needs to be a little bigger and the cookie needs to be a little smaller. Also the cookie sandwich was assembled flat instead of a wedge like cream which made it hard to eat.

Review №31

2022-08-08 00:41:28

Its a lovely place. At times its hard to find a clean table.

Review №32

2016-06-17 04:44:16

I hadnt realized that they had turned the old market into a little food court!The cookies were good and they had a great selection of ice cream flavors. Ube and their toasted almond were my favorites.

Review №33

2021-11-01 16:31:54

I thought my ice cream sundae was great. The flavor options were plenty and the employee was friendly.

Review №34

2021-06-28 04:25:32

Too many dessert options that you want all right now, but of course shouldnt if you want a sweet tooth coma....my favorite is the ice sandwich in a donut ❣️ Delicious unique ice cream flavors.

Review №35

2016-03-26 07:22:25

Fresh banana rocky road was so good!And had a taste of the lychee ice cream and it was also really good.Have yet to try the cookies though - thats next!

Review №36

2021-03-21 23:47:12

Always lots of interesting flavor choices, cones, cups, milkshakes and a few others. 2 free toppings with each cup/cone, plenty of choices there too.

Review №37

2019-07-25 16:12:29

I came here so stoned and would like to apologize to the 2 girls who took my order last night. I felt like I was being rude but I wasnt trying to be rude, I was just really really high. The ube dough-wich was sooo good.

Review №38

2019-07-20 20:30:56

First time there didnt know what to order. We tried the blackunicorn ice cream it was different but really good.

Review №39

2020-02-02 04:05:44

Great location next to many other food stalls. They have a lot of unique flavors. I recommend the Thai tea!

Review №40

2017-07-26 22:13:34

The cookie dough was pretty good, but the servings were way smaller than expected, especially for the price.

Review №41

2021-11-06 20:35:39

Found their options to be different but not to our liking. Usually a long wait for getting an ice cream on the weekends.

Review №42

2022-06-19 10:07:47

What a great place for kids an the ice cream

Review №43

2016-09-10 23:47:25

Yum. Doughnut with ice creams... that is all.

Review №44

2019-06-16 01:11:39

They were literally out of every single cookie. It’s 6pm on a Saturday. Second, they were also out of basically every waffle cone. How can you be a “milk and COOKIE bar” and out of everything: poor management

Review №45

2019-12-27 16:05:16

The variety of Ive cream and desserts they can make is awesome to see (and taste).

Review №46

2016-02-20 20:42:39

Amazing ice cream donut with unique ice cream flavors...gotta tryUsing non glazed donuts is the key

Review №47

2023-08-24 16:13:32

Unhygienic and was quite poor customer service

Review №48

2019-07-28 03:13:26

Loved this place, first time coming here love the location of it too really cool flavors

Review №49

2017-07-21 19:12:50

Great place for different kinds of ice cream treats.

Review №50

2023-03-26 02:06:20

Love the cookie monster ice cream

Review №51

2021-02-20 22:13:59

Some of the best ice cream Ive ever tasted

Review №52

2019-09-07 21:45:46

Amazing

Review №53

2018-02-25 21:29:48

Love this little place really delivers on the dessert but beware it Is a tad pricy

Review №54

2018-11-10 17:55:24

I like to get their mystery pint here. 3 for 15 dollars.

Review №55

2022-03-24 03:40:56

Unique flavors and quality ice cream

Review №56

2019-09-15 03:44:53

Good flavors and toppings. Worth the trip in 👍

Review №57

2019-08-11 21:12:37

Best ice cream in Castro Valley, scratch that... In the WORLD!

Review №58

2018-08-26 03:00:21

I love it I go here 2times a week or more

Review №59

2019-04-16 01:16:15

The best flavors ever

Review №60

2017-07-19 23:24:11

This place is amazing!