Poppy Cake Baking Company - Sierra Madre Location in Sierra Madre

Review №1

2023-11-30 21:11:17

Deviled egg salad sandwich was good. For the price of $12.50 I dont think it was worth it since it hardly had any egg salad, only lots of greens but I loved the taste. I would come back but only for the pastries. :)

Review №2

2023-09-13 05:17:23

We were actually on our way out of town and suddenly had a craving for a pastry of some kind as it was too late for breakfast but too early to grab lunch and we werent all that hungry. we were literally driving by when we saw the building and sign and decided to pull over across the street and walk over. i dont remember exactly what kind of small sandwich my partner ordered but they were pleased and it hit the spot for them and not being too full afterwards. i ordered the blueberry muffin which was delicious and they even warmed it up for me.

Review №3

2023-07-19 13:39:12

Poppy Cake Baking Co. Is a uniquely wonderful establishment. The quality, creativity and attention to detail is inspiring. Ive enjoyed everything Ive tried. Still working my way through the menu.

Review №4

2023-02-02 16:49:02

I got their seasonal cream cheese danish and a regular iced coffee. It was really good and the place looks cute too :) would definitely recommend

Review №5

2022-12-04 14:43:29

Tiny bakery but stuffed with lots of pastries, breads, salads, and other ready to take foods. They also make sandwiches and breakfast items and once I got some fried chicken! I dont like coffee, but everyone else I go with really loves it, so the coffee is good. They have good tea, but the hot chocolate is weak, so Id skip that. People are nice.

Review №6

2023-03-11 17:21:06

The service is friendly but they’re all trying to help each other with larger orders and no one verifying completeness but of course they charged full order with $8 avocado toast missing. And yet, I’ll be back because those damn chocolate almond croissants are ridiculously good.

Review №7

2023-06-19 06:08:47

Iced matcha is life changing. Im not exaggerating. Best matcha in the area. Too bad the service sucks.

Review №8

2022-02-02 18:12:56

I wanted to try this cafe after reading some great reviews. Although the shop is very cute and had many options - the customer service was much to be desired. I called in my order and first red flag was how rude the lady on the call was. I came in to pick up and let it go. I think the lady is the owner, she was just as rude and unfriendly in person. The brunette young lady at the register was very sweet and made the situation a lot better. If I’m spending money at your establishment, the least you can do is be courteous.Edit: everything I purchased was excellent. I appreciate the quick response to my review.

Review №9

2021-02-16 06:24:03

It was okay but I’ve definitely had better cakes. The citrus olive oil cake was good but the red velvet was way too dense.

Review №10

2023-11-21 21:45:49

Chicken pesto sandwich & cinnamon roll are delicious